When the System Becomes the Abuser: A Report on Institutional Betrayal

By: Samantha Syrnich — Restorative Justice Week
November 23-29th, 2025

I recently reviewed an amicus brief submitted to the U.S. Supreme Court, and I saw my family’s lived reality reflected in legal language.
The brief outlines the very patterns my children and I experienced firsthand: coercive control, system-enabled abuse, institutional blindness, and the repeated failure to prioritize child safety over procedure.

Key insights from the brief match what happened to us:

  • Abuse is not limited to physical violence. Coercive control, manipulation, intimidation, and system-abuse create prolonged, invisible danger.
  • My children were not bystanders. They were directly harmed — physically, psychologically, emotionally, and developmentally. Labeling them as “witnesses” minimizes what they actually endured.
  • Systems can be weaponized. Multiple abusers used institutional gaps to maintain control, while agencies dismissed, ignored, or misinterpreted the signs.
  • Paper protections often fail. Research confirms that safety promises and supervised‐visit “measures” break down in practice — something we personally experienced.
  • Procedure often outweighs safety. When institutions follow rigid steps instead of assessing actual risk, children are placed back in harm’s way.

Institutional betrayal is real.
It is preventable.
And the cost lands on children.

THIS IS RESTORATIVE JUSTICE WEEK,
a time to acknowledge harm, confront systemic failures, and advocate for trauma-informed reform. Survivors don’t need pity; we need institutional accountability and policy change that reflects the realities documented in this brief.

Full brief available here:
📄